AN INDEPENDENT READING ROOMFIRST EDITION · REVIEW COPY
The collectionPerson

Classical · c. 500–1200 CE

Bhāskara II: equations, surds, and mathematical astronomy

Read Bhāskara II through two algebraic examples, and distinguish his documented work from modern claims made on his behalf.

A name and a body of work

Bhāskara II, born in 1114, is also called Bhāskarācārya. The numeral distinguishes him from the earlier Bhāskara I. His writings include the arithmetic Līlāvatī and algebraic Bījagaṇita. These belong to the mathematical and astronomical programme associated with his Siddhāntaśiromaṇi, completed in 1150. 1 Colebrooke’s 1817 translation makes the arithmetic and algebra accessible in English, although its terminology and historical commentary require critical reading. 2

The most useful introduction is to work through a problem. Two examples below are modern teaching reconstructions, using present-day notation. They illustrate kinds of algebra treated in the Bījagaṇita; they are not quotations or transcriptions of Bhāskara’s calculations. 2

Finding another integer solution

Suppose we want whole numbers satisfying x² − 2y² = 1. The small pair x = 3, y = 2 works, because 9 − 8 = 1. A search through larger numbers would eventually find more pairs, but a transformation is more informative.

Starting with any solution, define X = 3x + 4y and Y = 2x + 3y. Expand the difference:

X² − 2Y² = (9x² + 24xy + 16y²) − (8x² + 24xy + 18y²) = x² − 2y².

The middle terms cancel. The new pair therefore solves the same equation. Beginning with (3, 2), we obtain (17, 12), then (99, 70). Direct checking gives 289 − 288 = 1 and 9801 − 9800 = 1.

This explains why a rule can outperform trial and error: it preserves an invariant, the value of x² − 2y². It also exposes the limits of our example. We have generated a sequence of solutions for one coefficient; we have not proved that we have found every positive solution, or explained a procedure for every nonsquare coefficient. Bhāskara’s treatment of the affected square and cyclic method addresses a wider setting. 2 For the simpler problem of a linear equation in integers, see the kuṭṭaka.

Taking apart a nested square root

Consider √(5 + 2√6). Look for an answer of the form √a + √b. Its square is a + b + 2√(ab), so we need a + b = 5 and ab = 6. Taking a = 2 and b = 3 gives

√(5 + 2√6) = √2 + √3.

Checking by squaring is essential. Because both expressions are positive, matching their squares establishes equality. Without that sign condition, squaring could hide a wrong choice of root. This is a useful reading habit for historical algorithms: distinguish the operation that produces a candidate from the argument that validates it.

Reading without retrospective labels

The arithmetic in these examples is exact, but the notation is modern. A compact symbolic identity is our explanation, not evidence that a medieval author wrote it in this form. Likewise, calling a historical technique “calculus” requires more argument than spotting a familiar-looking expression.

Read Līlāvatī for the relationship between a rule, a word problem, and a learner’s interpretation. Read Brahmagupta for an earlier mathematical setting. Comparing specific procedures gives a richer history than assigning a single modern title to an entire body of work.

Sources & notes

Numbers in the article point to these sources. Locators identify the passages used; modern worked examples are our own unless stated otherwise.

  1. Bhaskara II — MacTutor History of MathematicsJ. J. O’Connor and E. F. Robertson. Biography: names, dates, works, and discussion of the Līlāvatī legend.Source type: Reference work
  2. Algebra, with Arithmetic and Mensuration (1817)Brahmagupta and Bhāskara II; translated by Henry Thomas Colebrooke. Dissertation, pp. ii–iii; Bījagaṇita, chapter I, section V, and chapter III, sections I–II.Source type: Primary text / translation